Off Buck Lake Road, a short way from the Buck Lake neighborhood, Fallschase is being built behind the commercial strip with Costco, Bass Pro Shops and CMX Cinemas. Its developer is RMDC, Inc., and its plan calls for 321 single-family homes, 60 townhomes and a 288-unit apartment complex. Traton Homes' Oak Haven is a 119-home community along Mahan Drive, with its sales address at 4230 Oak Run Circle.
On the builder pages in mid-November 2026, D.R. Horton listed 16 available Fallschase homes from $339,900 to $675,900, and Traton listed Oak Haven inventory from $474,900 to $674,990. The prices overlap for most of the range, but the two communities are at different points in their build-out. Fallschase is large and still adding phases, and its shared amenity center is planned to follow Phases 7 and 8. Oak Haven is a smaller community, and Traton's community page lists its amenities alongside the homes for sale now. For a buyer comparing the two, the choice is mostly about timing.
Fallschase is a big community still in its middle phases
The plan has always been large. In 2022, the Tallahassee Democrat reported plans for a pool, clubhouse, pickleball courts, a gym and a community amphitheater, plus 81 acres placed in a land trust for a public park near Lake Lafayette, with trails running through the development. The walking trails already in place are association common areas. The association's amenity center page calls its drawings preliminary concepts that are subject to change.
The most recent timeline is in the minutes of the Fallschase Community Development District's May 4, 2026 board meeting. As of that meeting, the amenity center was not under construction, no HOA fees had been spent on it, and the developer was paying to keep the site's grass maintained. The board discussed building an amenity that owners could afford to maintain over the long term, a possible reduction in its scope, and setting aside reserves so homeowners can decide its future after the developers leave. The opening date it discussed was about 14 months after Phases 7 and 8 are complete and their certificates of occupancy are issued. The apartment complex is planned with a separate pool and clubhouse of its own.
The remaining phases depend on permits. At the same meeting, the board reported that the City of Tallahassee was holding further certificates of occupancy and permits until builders corrected their sidewalks, and that one builder, Premier, had finished most of its corrective work. The Fallschase Owners' Association had already held a March 25, 2026 update meeting on infrastructure and amenity status in response to homeowner questions about timelines. In practice, anyone buying in Fallschase now should plan to live through more construction, and should treat the amenity center as something that comes later, after the remaining phases are built.
Oak Haven is a 119-home build
Traton closed on the Oak Haven land on March 6, 2025. Its sales announcement describes eight floor plans of about 1,693 to 3,079 square feet. On the Oak Haven community page, Traton describes mature oaks, walking trails, a pool and cabana, pickleball courts and a dog park. With 119 homes, the community is roughly a third the size of the Fallschase single-family plan.
The two communities also price their monthly costs differently. A recent Traton listing showed Oak Haven HOA dues of $284 a month and listed lawn care and irrigation maintenance among the HOA services. The Fallschase association's homepage lists 2026 annual dues of $363, and a separate association notice announced an adjustment effective January 1, 2026. Fallschase homes also carry a yearly district assessment. The district's FY 2027 budget sets it at $880.28 to $1,245.24 for lots billed on the county tax roll, depending on lot type. These figures are general information as of their dates, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the charges for any specific home with the association, the district and your own advisors.
Where both price ranges sit in the metro market
Both communities are selling into a softer single-family market. Florida Realtors recorded a $329,950 median single-family sale price for the Tallahassee metro area in September 2026. The metro covers Gadsden, Jefferson, Leon and Wakulla counties, and that median was 5.7% lower than in September 2025, with closings down 6.2% to 259. Over the same month, the metro townhome and condo median rose 8.3% to $195,000.
Fallschase's lowest November asking price, $339,900, is about $10,000 above the September metro median for a single-family home. A buyer at that entry point is getting new construction at close to the area's typical price, in a community still in its middle phases. At the top of both ranges, near $675,000, the comparison comes down to which community is closer to finished. Oak Haven's builder describes a full amenity package for its 119 homes. Fallschase's amenity center is planned to follow Phases 7 and 8.
The retail around both communities is still changing. The Tallahassee Democrat reported in May 2026 that Sprouts Farmers Market is planned for 3111 Mahan Drive, in the former Big Lots space at Lafayette Place Shopping Center. For buyers who also want to look at the older homes and lake access just west of here, our Piney Z page covers that neighborhood.
Questions buyers ask about these two communities
When will the Fallschase amenity center open? At the May 4, 2026 district meeting, the board discussed an opening about 14 months after Phases 7 and 8 are complete and their certificates of occupancy are issued. It also discussed a possible reduction in the amenity's scope.
Will the Fallschase apartments share the neighborhood amenity? The apartment complex is planned with its own separate pool and clubhouse.
What does the Oak Haven HOA include? A recent Traton listing showed dues of $284 a month and listed lawn care and irrigation maintenance among the HOA services.
If you're weighing a Fallschase lot against an Oak Haven plan, The Tagoe Team can help you find out which phase each home sits in and what is still scheduled to be built around it before you write an offer. Work With Us.