Warm-white home entry with a timber door, bronze-framed window, limestone porch and a single fan palm beside a bordered planting bed.

Midtown Reader Turns 10 This Month. The Block Around It Has Changed More Than the Bookstore Has.

Which business at 1123 Thomasville Road has been there longest? As of this month, it's the bookstore. Midtown Reader celebrates its 10th birthday on Saturday, Oct. 10, with an all-day party at the shop. The sushi bar next door got close to the same mark. Izzy Pub & Sushi opened in 2017 and closed in September with a note on the door: "Izzy has permanently closed. Thanks for 10 great years!"

So Midtown Reader starts its second decade on a block that looks very different from a year ago. Look at how the changes happened, though, and a pattern shows up. Midtown has been renewing this corner by refilling rooms people already know, and often with people who already knew those rooms.

Ten years at one address, told through the doors around it

The bookstore stayed put while the spaces around it changed. Here is the order of events, pieced together from local reporting:

  1. 2017: Izzy Pub & Sushi opens next to Midtown Reader. Owner Viet Vu, a Tallahassee native, partnered with chef Xinzheng "Alex" Fang.
  2. June 2024: Sliders: A Sandwich Revolution closes at 1122 Thomasville Road, across the street, and the space stays empty.
  3. Jan. 18, 2026: Dear Sunday Cafe holds its soft opening at the bookstore's address.
  4. Aug. 30, 2026: The Tallahassee Democrat reports that Dear Sunday's owners are renovating the old Sliders space for a bakery called From Jane, with plans to open before year's end.
  5. Mid-September 2026: Tallahassee Foodies reports that From Jane expects to open in early October. On Sept. 18, the Democrat reports that Izzy has closed.
  6. Oct. 10, 2026: Midtown Reader turns 10.

So in under ten months, three of the spaces around the bookstore have changed hands or are about to. Most of those changes involve people the block already knew.

Dear Sunday cooks in a kitchen its chef has run before

Dear Sunday's executive chef, Erik Wheeler, has lived in Tallahassee for 16 years. Before Dear Sunday, the room was a Jeri's location, and Wheeler ran its kitchen then too. "I ran this kitchen when it was the Midtown Jeri's, so it feels like home here," he told the FSView in January. "I couldn't pass up an opportunity to return to this kitchen."

The menu is new even though the kitchen isn't. Everything is made from scratch, and the menu changes with the seasons. The FSView's review called the prime rib sandwich the standout handheld: thin-sliced prime rib on a toasted baguette with gruyere, caramelized onion and garlic aioli. Pancakes arrive under a tin cylinder full of toppings, which spill across the stack when you lift it. The cafe has seating inside and on the patio.

The owners weren't new either. The group behind Dear Sunday also owns BLND and Vice Society in CollegeTown, so the FSView noted that some of the staff might look familiar from those spots. Online listings currently show different hours for Dear Sunday, so check the cafe's own channels before you go.

From Jane is the second half of the same letter

The old Sliders space sat empty for more than two years before anyone took it on. The new tenant is the same five partners behind Dear Sunday: Aysia Sylvia, Tiffany Little, Courtney Atkins, Jackie Cook and Lelia Wolfe. Tallahassee Foodies reports that their roots run from Tallahassee and Crawfordville to Bainbridge, Georgia, and that Sylvia grew up in New Smyrna Beach.

They picked the name to match the cafe across the street.

"The two ends of a letter, two different ways to spend your mornings." Tiffany Little, co-owner, on how "Dear Sunday" opens the letter and "From Jane" signs it

Little also said Jane is the middle name of one of the partners' grandmothers. The bakery is modeled on a traditional European boulangerie. The planned menu includes artisan breads, croissants, morning buns, éclairs, tarts, custom cakes, grab-and-go sandwiches and seasonal items. You'll also be able to buy fresh flowers, along with drinks like matcha, cold brew and champagne.

The bakery itself already has a track record, even without a storefront. "We currently produce breads, pastries, and desserts for several local businesses but opening a storefront allows us to bring the products we already create, directly to our customers," Little said. The address is 1122 Thomasville Road #4 in the Manor at Midtown plaza. As of Oct. 4, we haven't found any report confirming the doors are open. The opening estimate has also moved, from "before the year comes to an end" in late August to "early October" in mid-September. Its Instagram, @itsfromjane, is the place to watch.

The open question is next door

Izzy's closing fits the same pattern, though so far it's the one space without a sequel. Vu's group has a history of turning over spaces in Midtown. The Democrat notes that his former Midtown restaurant, Taco Republik, ran for more than a decade, and El Rey's Tacos & Beer now occupies that space. As of early October, no local report has named a new tenant for the space next to Midtown Reader. If the past year is any guide, whoever moves in will probably have ties to Thomasville Road already. For now, the bookstore's neighbor is an empty room with a thank-you note on the door.

What the bookstore has planned for its second decade

The bookstore marks the anniversary with a full calendar. The birthday weekend actually starts the night before, and storytimes continue through Thanksgiving weekend. Everything below is at 1123 Thomasville Road.

  • Friday, Oct. 9, 6:30 to 7:30 p.m.: Banned Book Bingo closes out Banned Books Week, with drinks.
  • Saturday, Oct. 10, all day: The 10th birthday party. At 11 a.m., Kidtown storytime brings in Greenfire Farms with baby chicks, and a local author meet-and-greet runs from noon to 3 p.m.
  • Saturday, Oct. 17, 3 to 5 p.m.: Signing with local authors Alessandra Nysether-Santos, S.D. Miller and Ralph Clotaire Jean.
  • Thursday, Oct. 22, 6:30 to 7:30 p.m.: Tallahassee author Susan Cerulean discusses The Call to a Wilder Wisdom with local author Doug Alderson.
  • Sunday, Oct. 25: Haint Season with Caylee, an afternoon of Southern ghost stories. The session repeats Nov. 22.
  • Thursday, Oct. 29, 6:30 to 7:30 p.m.: Voices of Tallahassee, a group reading from The Panacea Review, which the store calls the Panhandle's newest literary magazine. Readers include Cerulean and poets Sandra Simonds and Zachary Scott.
  • Saturday, Oct. 31: Kidtown with the Tallahassee Fire Department at 11 a.m., with a real fire truck visiting the store. A Horror Book Swap follows at 4 p.m.

Kidtown Storytime runs on Saturday mornings in November, ending Nov. 28. Event pages sometimes change, so confirm times on the store's calendar the week you plan to go.

A birthday Saturday on one block

You can spend most of Oct. 10 without leaving this corner. Have brunch at Dear Sunday, then catch the baby chicks at Kidtown next door at 11. The author meet-and-greet starts at noon. If From Jane has opened by then, it's directly across the street for bread or a cake to take home.

When Lindsay and Shehu Tagoe talk with Midtown buyers and sellers, a lot of the conversation is about blocks like this one: what moved in, what moved out, and how fast empty spaces get filled. If you're tracking how Thomasville Road is changing and wondering what it means for a home nearby, The Tagoe Team can walk you through it street by street. Work With Us.

Work With Us

Experience real estate like never before with The Tagoe Team. Our expertise, vibrant approach, and personalized service make your journey seamless and rewarding. Discover what sets us apart in the Tallahassee market.

Follow Me on Instagram