Cream painted-brick two-story home with black shutters, a timber entry door, a broad lawn and a mature live oak.

Under Amendment 3, a Tallahassee Buyer's Residency Date Matters More Than the Closing Date

Two buyers could close on the same Tallahassee street on the same day in March 2027, at the same price, and get very different property tax treatment for years. If Florida voters approve Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026, the difference comes from one date on the calendar: December 31, 2026. According to the Leon County Property Appraiser, anyone who was a permanent Florida resident by then qualifies for the larger homestead exemption from the start. Anyone who becomes a resident on January 1, 2027 or later starts lower and waits.

The Leon County Property Appraiser reads that cutoff as a residency test, separate from when you buy. Its guidance says people who establish Florida residency by December 31, 2026, would be eligible for the higher exemption whenever they later buy and apply for homestead. The Florida Policy Institute reads the text differently. It argues the amendment never defines "establish Florida residency" for people who don't own property, because Florida homestead law ties residency terms to owners, so renters may not qualify unless they own a homestead by the end of 2026. Implementing legislation would settle the question. Until then, the move date can matter as much as the closing date for anyone relocating to Leon County for a state job, a university position, or a hospital role, and it's unclear whether a resident who rents through the cutoff is covered.

Amendment 3 needs at least 60% of the vote to pass. An NBC 6/Telemundo poll by Mason-Dixon, taken September 28 to October 1, 2026 among 625 likely voters, found 55% in favor, 26% opposed, and 19% undecided, with a margin of error of plus or minus 4 points. That level of support is short of the threshold, and nearly one voter in five hasn't decided. The rest of this post explains how the rules would work if the amendment passes. It doesn't predict the outcome.

What would change on a Leon County homestead

For the 2026 tax year, a qualifying Florida homestead gets up to $51,411 in exemptions. Of that, $25,000 applies to all taxes, school taxes included, and an extra $26,411 applies only to non-school taxes.

Amendment 3 would replace that setup with a $25,000 exemption for school taxes and a non-school exemption of up to $150,000 starting January 1, 2027. That rises to up to $250,000 on January 1, 2028, with yearly inflation adjustments starting in 2029. Homeowners would first see the change on the August 2027 TRIM notices and on the tax bills mailed in November 2027.

School taxes stay in place. Only the first $25,000 of assessed value would remain exempt from them, so most owners would still get a tax bill. Save Our Homes stays in place too, which keeps annual assessed-value increases on a homestead to 3% or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower. Portability rules don't change.

Why recent buyers would gain the most

Save Our Homes still being in force is what drives this. A longtime owner's assessed value has grown by no more than 3% a year, so it often sits well below market value. A buyer who just closed has an assessed value close to the purchase price. The Property Appraiser's office says recent buyers "may be more likely to receive the full benefit of the proposed exemption." For existing owners, the effect depends on how much Save Our Homes benefit they've built up. The Florida Policy Institute explains the same gap between long-held assessments and a new owner's market-based starting value.

The table below uses hypothetical round numbers to show non-school taxable value only. It shows how much taxable value each exemption takes away. It isn't a tax estimate. The Property Appraiser says exact savings can't be calculated until implementing legislation is passed and future millage rates are set.

Hypothetical homestead, 2028 Assessed value Non-school exemption Non-school taxable value Taxable value removed vs. today's $51,411
Longtime owner with a large Save Our Homes gap $140,000 Up to $250,000, capped at assessed value $0 $88,589
Recent buyer, Florida resident by Dec. 31, 2026 $300,000 $250,000 $50,000 $198,589
Recent buyer, new resident in 2027 $300,000 About $50,000 new-resident amount, CPI-adjusted from 2028 About $250,000 About the same as today

The longtime owner's non-school taxable value falls to zero, but the removable amount was small to begin with. The resident who bought recently gets the largest reduction in taxable value. The newcomer who bought the same house for the same price is left about where homesteads are today.

To put a rate next to those numbers: on September 22, 2026, Leon County adopted a countywide millage of 8.3144 mills and an Emergency Medical Services MSTU rate of 0.7500 mills. City of Tallahassee and school rates also appear on a bill. The figures we have for those are tentative or proposed, so we haven't applied them here.

How the new-resident waiting period works

Under the amendment, someone who wasn't a Florida resident on December 31, 2026 would get the $50,000 non-school exemption once they qualify for homestead. The Property Appraiser says that amount would be adjusted for inflation each year starting in 2028. The larger exemption would start in their fifth year of exemption. According to Leon County's FAQ, the five-year count starts in the year the exemption is first claimed. The date you moved doesn't start it.

Here's how that plays out for a hypothetical buyer who moves to Tallahassee in mid-2027, rents first, and buys later:

  1. 2027: they become a Florida resident. No homestead yet, so the clock hasn't started.
  2. 2028: they buy and claim homestead for the first time. This is year one, at the new-resident amount of about $50,000.
  3. 2029 through 2031: years two through four, still at the new-resident amount.
  4. 2032: year five, the first year the larger exemption applies.

The waiting period doesn't apply to current Florida homestead owners. The ballot text applies the rule "to the extent permitted by the U.S. Constitution," and the Property Appraiser notes that implementing legislation could add more administrative procedures. The one court case over the amendment dealt with the ballot language. It didn't challenge the waiting period. We haven't found any lawsuit aimed at the new-resident provision.

What the language fight changed, and what it didn't

On August 4, 2026, Leon County Circuit Judge David Frank ruled that the amendment's original title, "Save Our Homes from Excessive Property Taxes," was "akin to a political slogan," Florida Phoenix reported. Revised language filed on August 13 uses the title "Increased Homestead Exemption; Lower Cap on Increases in Non-Homestead Property Assessments." The Leon Clerk's docket shows the state declined to appeal and the plaintiffs declined to challenge the new wording. Leon County says the amendment's substance didn't change and it stays on the ballot as Amendment 3.

The rewritten summary describes a feature the old title didn't. It directs the Legislature to create a uniform procedure that counties and cities could use to raise the homestead exemption up to a property's full assessed value. Special districts could do the same if voters approve in a referendum. The Property Appraiser says the timing and size of any increase beyond $250,000 can't be known yet.

Where the lost revenue goes

A buyer comparing tax bills should also look at the services those taxes pay for. Leon County estimates that the $250,000 exemption plus the 5% non-homestead cap would cut county property tax revenue by about $70.7 million a year once fully phased in. After state mandates and constitutional officers are paid, the county says about $3.5 million would be left for everything else. Leon County's property tax FAQ says the property-tax-funded EMS MSTU could mean "fewer ambulances and slower response times."

Raising the millage rate to cover the gap would be harder than before. Under a companion law, SB 4-F, a simple majority of the county board can set a rate only up to the rolled-back rate. Going above that takes a two-thirds vote. Going above 110% of the rolled-back rate takes a unanimous board vote or a referendum. The county lists other options it could weigh, including solid waste, stormwater, fire service, impact, and permit fees. Fees like these apply whether or not a home has a homestead exemption.

The City of Tallahassee faces a smaller version of the same problem. Tallahassee Reports reported in June 2026 on a city budget workshop that projected property tax losses of $11.2 million in FY 2028 and $17.8 million in FY 2029. The FY 2028 figure is about 4.8% of projected General Fund revenue. The same report said about 25,500 of the city's 89,000 households, or 28.6%, would benefit directly. Those are early workshop estimates, not adopted budget figures.

The investor side of the ballot

Rentals, second homes, and investment properties can't get the larger homestead exemption. Their part of the amendment is the drop in the annual non-homestead assessment cap from 10% to 5%. The Property Appraiser notes that this caps assessed value, not the tax itself. School taxes on these properties would stay uncapped and keep tracking market value. If you own a campus-area rental, the change slows how fast your assessment can grow. Your bill still depends on millage rates and any new fees.

Frequently asked questions

If I'm already a Florida resident but haven't bought yet, do I lose out by waiting until 2027 to buy? According to the Property Appraiser, residents as of December 31, 2026 would be eligible for the higher exemption whenever they buy and apply for homestead. The Florida Policy Institute argues the amendment's wording leaves that open for people who rent through the cutoff, so it may come down to implementing legislation.

I'm moving from another Leon County home. Does portability still work? The amendment doesn't change Florida's portability rules.

If it passes and the results disappoint, can it be undone? Leon County says bringing back the lost revenue would take another constitutional amendment approved by voters statewide.

Do senior, veteran, or disability exemptions change? No. The amendment leaves existing personal exemptions as they are.

If you're relocating to Tallahassee and your move date, lease, or closing could fall on either side of December 31, talk with The Tagoe Team early. We'll go over how the timing works with you and point you to the Leon County Property Appraiser for answers about your own exemption.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Us

Experience real estate like never before with The Tagoe Team. Our expertise, vibrant approach, and personalized service make your journey seamless and rewarding. Discover what sets us apart in the Tallahassee market.

Follow Me on Instagram